Diskussion:Liste der InterRegio-Bahnhöfe der Schweiz
Aufteilung nach Kantone?
BearbeitenMuss das wirklich nach Kantone gegliedert sein, das verunmöglicht jegdliche Sortierung. Warum nicht ein einzige "sortable" Tabelle mit Kantone als Tabellenspalte? --Filzstift (Diskussion) 08:49, 27. Sep. 2022 (CEST)
- Durch Vereinigung obsolet. --Filzstift (Diskussion) 09:12, 7. Nov. 2022 (CET)
Karte
Bearbeiten
Wiederholt wird nebenstehende Karte eingefügt. Diese erachte ich nicht als hilfreich: Es ist ein Browser-Screenshot von einer OSM-Anwendung samt eingeblendetem Popup. Was möglich wäre, wäre das Verlinken eines solchen Layer im Abschnitt "Weblinks". Nicht aber in Form eines PNGs. Gut wäre es, wenn man die Browser-Elemente (wie die +/- Knöpfe, das Popup sowieso etc. nicht mit drinnen wären, zudem mit verbessertem Kontrast für Benutzer mit Sehschwächen - wir haben hier teils Grün auf Grün). --Filzstift (Diskussion) 09:57, 27. Sep. 2022 (CEST)
- It's still a relevant map and it's more complete than the list on this page. I don't see a requirement for maps being in "weblinks". Coloring is a design decision by the map application's programmer and used elsewhere on Wikimedia websites, also in German Wikipedia. The displayed image is explained on the file description page. I would understand if the map was replaced by something more of your liking, but deleting it just makes the entire list less helpful. Another design could be requested in a graphic lab and used to replace this map once available (Sorry for my English, please respond in German). Enhancing999 (Diskussion) 10:10, 27. Sep. 2022 (CEST)
- We have somewhat minimum standards how to illustrate an article. These are soft rules. According to Wikipedia:Artikel_illustrieren an illustration should improve the article. Therefore the image selection should be done carefully. A map with all InterRegion stations - even in given color - may be acceptable (but no more), but here even the minimum standards are not fulfilled: With that mouse-over(?) mistake, the opened overlay showing a historic view of the railway station Leuk. I assume it's taken from a web page (based on OSM) showing such overlays. Why not linking that service - rather than that static image? --Filzstift (Diskussion) 11:45, 27. Sep. 2022 (CEST)
- A map is indeed an improvement for this list. What you see as a mistake is a deliberate choice, as the map is based on image locations, rather than station locations directly. Still, this leads to a more complete picture than this page with Switzerland's 18 cantons. If we preferred linking outside Wikipedia, we would replace this list with a sbb.ch page. I don't understand why you don't like maps with inserts. If you prefer another format, why not design one? --Enhancing999 (Diskussion) 12:38, 27. Sep. 2022 (CEST)
- Did I understood this correctly? The overlay at Leuk was a deliberate choice? --Filzstift (Diskussion) 15:24, 27. Sep. 2022 (CEST)
- A map is indeed an improvement for this list. What you see as a mistake is a deliberate choice, as the map is based on image locations, rather than station locations directly. Still, this leads to a more complete picture than this page with Switzerland's 18 cantons. If we preferred linking outside Wikipedia, we would replace this list with a sbb.ch page. I don't understand why you don't like maps with inserts. If you prefer another format, why not design one? --Enhancing999 (Diskussion) 12:38, 27. Sep. 2022 (CEST)
- We have somewhat minimum standards how to illustrate an article. These are soft rules. According to Wikipedia:Artikel_illustrieren an illustration should improve the article. Therefore the image selection should be done carefully. A map with all InterRegion stations - even in given color - may be acceptable (but no more), but here even the minimum standards are not fulfilled: With that mouse-over(?) mistake, the opened overlay showing a historic view of the railway station Leuk. I assume it's taken from a web page (based on OSM) showing such overlays. Why not linking that service - rather than that static image? --Filzstift (Diskussion) 11:45, 27. Sep. 2022 (CEST)